Workout arrangement definition
/What is a Workout Arrangement?
A workout arrangement is an out-of-court agreement between creditors and a debtor to revise the debtor's payments to the satisfaction of all parties. A loan workout can involve a variety of adjustments to the original loan agreement, such as spreading the payments over a longer period of time or writing off part of the loan balance. Other options are to reduce the interest rate on the loan, or replace some or all of the debt with equity ownership in the debtor. The essential forms of a workout are as follows:
Standstill agreement. The creditors agree to halt their collection activities for a period of time, to let the debtor straighten out its financial and operational situation.
Restructuring agreement. The creditors agree to reduce some portion of their claims against the debtor, usually in exchange for an equity position in the debtor.
It is only possible to enter into a workout arrangement when it is to the advantage of both parties; otherwise, one party or the other will not agree to its terms.
Related AccountingTools Courses
Effective Corporate Turnarounds
Essentials of Corporate Bankruptcy
Benefits of a Workout Arrangement
A creditor has an interest in allowing these adjustments, since the alternative may be the bankruptcy of the debtor or its complete nonpayment of amounts owed, which will require the creditor to engage in expensive legal alternatives. The owners of the debtor can also find a workout to be a reasonable alternative to bankruptcy, since it may allow them to retain some or all of their existing ownership of the business, while also avoiding the costs of bankruptcy. In addition, a workout is a less public activity than a bankruptcy, so customers are less likely to be aware of it.
Problems with Workout Arrangements
Workout arrangements in a bankruptcy context can present several challenges. Here is a list of common problems:
Non-compliance with bankruptcy laws. Workouts must align with bankruptcy law provisions, such as the automatic stay, which prohibits creditors from pursuing collection activities outside of court proceedings.
Lack of formal structure. Unlike formal bankruptcy proceedings, workouts lack a court-supervised framework, potentially leading to inconsistent treatment of creditors.
Preferential payments. Creditors may demand preferential treatment, risking clawback actions if the workout fails and bankruptcy is later filed.
Fails to gain total agreement. Unanimous agreement among creditors is often required for a workout to succeed, which can be difficult to achieve.
Unrealistic projections. Workouts often rely on overly optimistic revenue or expense projections that can lead to failure if not met.
Creditor distrust. Creditors may distrust the debtor’s management, making negotiations contentious and difficult.
Power imbalance. Dominant creditors may impose terms that are less favorable to smaller creditors or the debtor.
Conflicting interests. Creditors with different priorities, such as secured versus unsecured lenders, may have competing goals.
Loss of stakeholder confidence. Ongoing financial struggles and public knowledge of a workout can erode customer, supplier, and employee trust.
Addressing these issues requires careful planning, clear communication, and the involvement of experienced legal and financial advisors.